Frequently Asked Questions

What happens to merchandise that does not sell in the store?

Merchandise that doesn’t sell in our stores is brought to our Outlet Store located at 10633 Glendale Road in Woodlawn, which is open seven days a week (Monday–Saturday 9 a.m.–8 p.m. and Sunday 10 a.m.–6 p.m.). At the Outlet, clothing is sold by the pound ($1.89/lb.), and other non-clothing items are available at deeply discounted prices.

If items do not sell at the Outlet, clothing and textiles are sent to our onsite Recycling Facility, where they are repurposed to support global markets. Materials that cannot be utilized overseas are given a second life through innovative recycling processes, such as being transformed into wiping cloths, industrial gloves, or other practical products.

This multi-step process ensures that we minimize waste and maximize the impact of your donations. Every purchase helps support our mission of changing lives through job training and employment programs.

How can I be sure that the infant and children's items you sell are safe?

Each month the Consumer Safety Product Commission sends Goodwill the latest recall notices. This information is reviewed with each of our inspection and pricing team members and a copy of the notice is kept on file in their work area for reference. The identified items are removed from the shelves and are not available for purchase.

Why are your prices higher than I expected, especially since the items are donated?

At Ohio Valley Goodwill, we work hard to offer affordable prices while ensuring that the revenue from our sales directly supports our mission. While the items are generously donated, the costs of processing, sorting, and selling them do contribute to the pricing. However, we’re proud to share that 85 cents of every dollar spent in our stores goes directly to funding our job training, employment services, and support programs for individuals with disabilities and other barriers to employment. We deeply appreciate our shoppers and donors—your contributions help us make a lasting impact in the community and assist low-income families, individuals facing financial challenges, and those seeking career support. Thank you for supporting Goodwill and helping us continue this important work!

When I'm shopping at Goodwill and see an item I might want to purchase, will you hold it for me?

Unfortunately, due to the one-of-a-kind nature of our business, we are unable to hold things. All merchandise is sold on a first-come, first-served basis.

Who determines the prices on items and what is that based on?

Goodwill prices are standardized and based on the Fair Market Value sheet which provides the price at which our stores are able to sell donated items. These prices have been carefully researched over a period of years and reflect the current Fair Market Value of each item listed.

Recently while shopping in a Goodwill store I overheard a man trying to convince the manager to sell him an item at a reduced price. Is that a common practice?

Occasionally, people will ask for an item to be discounted. It is very rare that a price would be reduced. Lowering prices on request is not a common practice for any retailer and we have adopted that as our policy as well.

My neighbor told me Goodwill employees get first option of purchasing items donated. Is that true?

Goodwill has a Fairness Policy which states that ” since our goods come from public donations, it’s only fair that every customer has an equal opportunity to purchase any items for sale here. That is why anyone who works or volunteers in a particular Goodwill store is not permitted to shop there for themselves or others.”

I made a donation last week and the man that gave me the receipt would not put the value on my items on the receipt. I thought Goodwill was responsible for that?

When donations are made to Goodwill a receipt is provided. The donor is asked to fill out the receipt with an itemized listing of the donation items, if they plan to claim it on your taxes. Goodwill will also provide a Fair Market Value sheet that can be used as a guide to establish the value of your items. Tax professionals advise donors to determine the value of their items. Donors would then be prepared to address any questions the IRS may have. IRS inquiries are always directed to the taxpayer not to the recipient of the donation. For more information about guidelines for Charitable Donations, you may wish to consult www.irs.gov.

Can I return items I bought at a Goodwill store?

Currently, only clothing can be returned for an in-store credit with receipt within ten days of purchase. This excludes sale items.

Can I buy something at Goodwill that does not have a price on it?

Items without a price will NOT be sold. Unpriced items will be reprocessed at an undisclosed time.